The consensus 1931 College Basketball All-American team, as determined by aggregating the results of two major All-American teams. To earn "consensus" status, a player must win honors from a majority of the following teams: the Helms Athletic Foundation and College Humor Magazine.

1931 Consensus All-America team

Consensus Team
PlayerClassTeam
Wes FeslerSeniorOhio State
George GregorySeniorColumbia
Joe ReiffSophomoreNorthwestern
Elwood RomneySophomoreBrigham Young
John WoodenJuniorPurdue

Individual All-America teams

All-America Team
First teamSecond teamThird team
PlayerSchoolPlayerSchoolPlayerSchool
HelmsBoze BergerMarylandNo second or third teams
Ralph CairneyWashington
Bart CarltonAda Teachers
Wes FeslerOhio State
George GregoryColumbia
Dick LinthicumUCLA
Joe ReiffNorthwestern
Elwood RomneyBrigham Young
Carey SpicerKentucky
John WoodenPurdue
College HumorMax CollingsMissouriWeb CaldwellSouthern CaliforniaKeith ArioMontana State
Lindy HoodAlabamaWes FeslerOhio StateLouis HaymanSyracuse
Max PosnakSt. John'sGeorge GregoryColumbiaDon MaclayNebraska
Joe ReiffNorthwesternJohn KriegerProvidenceElwood RomneyBrigham Young
John WoodenPurdueRay SteckerArmyJames SextonArkansas

See also