| Offense Position Players Quarterbacks Y. A. Tittle, New York Giants Johnny Unitas, Baltimore Colts Running backs Tommy Mason, Minnesota Vikings Jim Brown, Cleveland Browns Tom Moore, Green Bay Packers Jim Taylor, Green Bay Packers Wide receivers Bobby Joe Conrad, St. Louis Cardinals (Flanker) Del Shofner, New York Giants (Split End) Terry Barr, Detroit Lions (Flanker) Bobby Mitchell, Washington Redskins Gail Cogdill, Detroit Lions (Split End) Buddy Dial, Pittsburgh Steelers (Split End) Sonny Randle, St. Louis Cardinals (Split End) Tight ends Mike Ditka, Chicago Bears Ron Kramer, Green Bay Pete Retzlaff, Philadelphia Eagles Tackles Dick Schafrath, Left, Cleveland Browns Forrest Gregg, Right, Green Bay Packers Charlie Bradshaw, Left, Pittsburgh Steelers Rosey Brown, Left, New York Giants Bob St. Clair, Right, San Francisco 49ers Bob Wetoska, Right, Chicago Bears Guards Jim Parker, Left, Baltimore Colts Jerry Kramer, Right, Green Bay Packers Darrell Dess, Left, New York Giants Fuzzy Thurston, Left, Green Bay Packers John Gordy, Right, Detroit Lions Ken Gray, Right, St. Louis Cardinals Centers Jim Ringo, Green Bay Packers Buzz Nutter, Pittsburgh Steelers Mike Pyle, Chicago Bears | Defense Position Players Defensive ends Jim Katcavage, Left, New York Giants Doug Atkins, Right, Chicago Bears Willie Davis, Left, Green Bay Packers Gino Marchetti, Baltimore Colts Bill Glass, Cleveland Browns Defensive tackles Roger Brown, Right, Detroit Lions Henry Jordan, Right, Green Bay Packers Bob Gain, Left, Cleveland Browns Dick Modzelewski, Left, New York Giants Merlin Olsen, Left, Los Angeles Rams Rosey Grier, Right, Los Angeles Rams Luke Owens, Right, St. Louis Cardinals Outside Linebackers Joe Fortunato, Left, Chicago Bears Jack Pardee, Right, Los Angeles Rams Dan Currie, Left, Green Bay Packers Chuck Howley, Left, Dallas Cowboys Bill Forester, Green Bay Packers Bill Koman, St. Louis Cardinals Larry Morris, Chicago Bears Wayne H. Walker, Detroit Lions Middle Linebackers Bill George, Chicago Bears Rip Hawkins, Minnesota Vikings Sam Huff, New York Giants Ray Nitschke, Green Bay Packers Myron Pottios, Pittsburgh Steelers Cornerbacks Herb Adderly, Left, Green Bay Packers Dick Lynch, Right, New York Giants Dick "Night Train" Lane, Left, Detroit Lions Eddie Meador, Left, Los Angeles Rams Jimmy Hill, Right, St. Louis Cardinals Abe Woodson, Right, San Francisco 49ers Safety Richie Petitbon, Left, Chicago Bears Roosevelt Taylor, Right, Chicago Bears Clendon Thomas, Left, Pittsburgh Steelers Yale Lary, Right, Detroit Lions Jimmy Patton, Right New York Giants Larry Wilson, Right, St. Louis Cardinals Willie Wood, Right, Green Bay Packers | Special teams Position Players Returners Timmy Brown, Philadelphia Eagles |
| Position | Players |
| Quarterbacks | Y. A. Tittle, New York Giants Johnny Unitas, Baltimore Colts |
| Running backs | Tommy Mason, Minnesota Vikings Jim Brown, Cleveland Browns Tom Moore, Green Bay Packers Jim Taylor, Green Bay Packers |
| Wide receivers | Bobby Joe Conrad, St. Louis Cardinals (Flanker) Del Shofner, New York Giants (Split End) Terry Barr, Detroit Lions (Flanker) Bobby Mitchell, Washington Redskins Gail Cogdill, Detroit Lions (Split End) Buddy Dial, Pittsburgh Steelers (Split End) Sonny Randle, St. Louis Cardinals (Split End) |
| Tight ends | Mike Ditka, Chicago Bears Ron Kramer, Green Bay Pete Retzlaff, Philadelphia Eagles |
| Tackles | Dick Schafrath, Left, Cleveland Browns Forrest Gregg, Right, Green Bay Packers Charlie Bradshaw, Left, Pittsburgh Steelers Rosey Brown, Left, New York Giants Bob St. Clair, Right, San Francisco 49ers Bob Wetoska, Right, Chicago Bears |
| Guards | Jim Parker, Left, Baltimore Colts Jerry Kramer, Right, Green Bay Packers Darrell Dess, Left, New York Giants Fuzzy Thurston, Left, Green Bay Packers John Gordy, Right, Detroit Lions Ken Gray, Right, St. Louis Cardinals |
| Centers | Jim Ringo, Green Bay Packers Buzz Nutter, Pittsburgh Steelers Mike Pyle, Chicago Bears |
| Defense |
| Position | Players |
| Defensive ends | Jim Katcavage, Left, New York Giants Doug Atkins, Right, Chicago Bears Willie Davis, Left, Green Bay Packers Gino Marchetti, Baltimore Colts Bill Glass, Cleveland Browns |
| Defensive tackles | Roger Brown, Right, Detroit Lions Henry Jordan, Right, Green Bay Packers Bob Gain, Left, Cleveland Browns Dick Modzelewski, Left, New York Giants Merlin Olsen, Left, Los Angeles Rams Rosey Grier, Right, Los Angeles Rams Luke Owens, Right, St. Louis Cardinals |
| Outside Linebackers | Joe Fortunato, Left, Chicago Bears Jack Pardee, Right, Los Angeles Rams Dan Currie, Left, Green Bay Packers Chuck Howley, Left, Dallas Cowboys Bill Forester, Green Bay Packers Bill Koman, St. Louis Cardinals Larry Morris, Chicago Bears Wayne H. Walker, Detroit Lions |
| Middle Linebackers | Bill George, Chicago Bears Rip Hawkins, Minnesota Vikings Sam Huff, New York Giants Ray Nitschke, Green Bay Packers Myron Pottios, Pittsburgh Steelers |
| Cornerbacks | Herb Adderly, Left, Green Bay Packers Dick Lynch, Right, New York Giants Dick "Night Train" Lane, Left, Detroit Lions Eddie Meador, Left, Los Angeles Rams Jimmy Hill, Right, St. Louis Cardinals Abe Woodson, Right, San Francisco 49ers |
| Safety | Richie Petitbon, Left, Chicago Bears Roosevelt Taylor, Right, Chicago Bears Clendon Thomas, Left, Pittsburgh Steelers Yale Lary, Right, Detroit Lions Jimmy Patton, Right New York Giants Larry Wilson, Right, St. Louis Cardinals Willie Wood, Right, Green Bay Packers |
| Special teams |
| Position | Players |
| Returners | Timmy Brown, Philadelphia Eagles |