| Offense Position Players Quarterbacks Johnny Unitas, Baltimore Colts Sonny Jurgensen, Washington Redskins Halfbacks Leroy Kelly, Cleveland Browns Dave Osborn, Minnesota Vikings Gale Sayers, Chicago Bears Fullbacks Don Perkins, Dallas Cowboys Johnny Roland, St. Louis Cardinals Wide receivers/flankers Gary Collins, Cleveland Browns Willie Richardson, Baltimore Colts Pat Studstill, Detroit Lions Wide receivers/split ends Boyd Dowler, Green Bay Packers Bob Hayes, Dallas Cowboys Homer Jones, New York Giants Charley Taylor, Washington Redskins Tight ends John Mackey, Baltimore Colts Jackie Smith, St. Louis Cardinals Jerry Smith, Washington Redskins Tackles Bob Vogel (LT), Baltimore Colts Bob Brown (RT), Philadelphia Eagles Charley Cowan (RT), Los Angeles Rams Forrest Gregg (RT), Green Bay Packers Ernie McMillan (RT), St. Louis Cardinals Ralph Neely (RT), Dallas Cowboys Guards John Gordy (RG), Detroit Lions Ken Gray (RG), St. Louis Cardinals Gene Hickerson(RG), Cleveland Browns Jerry Kramer (RG), Green Bay Packers Howard Mudd(RG), San Francisco 49ers Centers Bob DeMarco, St. Louis Cardinals Mick Tingelhoff, Minnesota Vikings | Defense Position Players Left defensive ends Willie Davis, Green Bay Packers Carl Eller, Minnesota Vikings Deacon Jones, Los Angeles Rams Right defensive ends George Andrie, Dallas Cowboys Ordell Braase, Baltimore Colts Bill Glass, Cleveland Browns Lamar Lundy, Los Angeles Rams Left defensive tackles Alex Karras, Detroit Lions Fred Miller, Baltimore Colts Merlin Olsen, Los Angeles Rams Floyd Peters, Philadelphia Eagles Right defensive tackles Henry Jordan, Green Bay Packers Bob Lilly, Dallas Cowboys Chuck Walker, St. Louis Cardinals Outside linebackers Chuck Howley (Left), Dallas Cowboys Dave Robinson (Left), Green Bay Packers Dave Wilcox (Left), San Francisco 49ers Maxie Baughan (Right), Los Angeles Rams Andy Russell (Right), Pittsburgh Steelers Inside/middle linebackers Dick Butkus, Chicago Bears Dale Meinert, St. Louis Cardinals Ray Nitschke, Green Bay Packers Tommy Nobis, Atlanta Falcons Cornerbacks Herb Adderly, Green Bay Packers Lem Barney, Detroit Lions Bobby Boyd, Baltimore Colts Cornell Green, Dallas Cowboys Dave Whitsell, New Orleans Saints Bob Jeter, Green Bay Packers Safety Richie Petitbon, Chicago Bears Eddie Meador, Los Angeles Rams Mel Renfro, Dallas Cowboys Larry Wilson, St. Louis Cardinals Willie Wood, Green Bay Packers | Special teams Position Players Kickers Jim Bakken, St. Louis Cardinals Don Chandler, Green Bay Packers |
| Position | Players |
| Quarterbacks | Johnny Unitas, Baltimore Colts Sonny Jurgensen, Washington Redskins |
| Halfbacks | Leroy Kelly, Cleveland Browns Dave Osborn, Minnesota Vikings Gale Sayers, Chicago Bears |
| Fullbacks | Don Perkins, Dallas Cowboys Johnny Roland, St. Louis Cardinals |
| Wide receivers/flankers | Gary Collins, Cleveland Browns Willie Richardson, Baltimore Colts Pat Studstill, Detroit Lions |
| Wide receivers/split ends | Boyd Dowler, Green Bay Packers Bob Hayes, Dallas Cowboys Homer Jones, New York Giants Charley Taylor, Washington Redskins |
| Tight ends | John Mackey, Baltimore Colts Jackie Smith, St. Louis Cardinals Jerry Smith, Washington Redskins |
| Tackles | Bob Vogel (LT), Baltimore Colts Bob Brown (RT), Philadelphia Eagles Charley Cowan (RT), Los Angeles Rams Forrest Gregg (RT), Green Bay Packers Ernie McMillan (RT), St. Louis Cardinals Ralph Neely (RT), Dallas Cowboys |
| Guards | John Gordy (RG), Detroit Lions Ken Gray (RG), St. Louis Cardinals Gene Hickerson(RG), Cleveland Browns Jerry Kramer (RG), Green Bay Packers Howard Mudd(RG), San Francisco 49ers |
| Centers | Bob DeMarco, St. Louis Cardinals Mick Tingelhoff, Minnesota Vikings |
| Defense |
| Position | Players |
| Left defensive ends | Willie Davis, Green Bay Packers Carl Eller, Minnesota Vikings Deacon Jones, Los Angeles Rams |
| Right defensive ends | George Andrie, Dallas Cowboys Ordell Braase, Baltimore Colts Bill Glass, Cleveland Browns Lamar Lundy, Los Angeles Rams |
| Left defensive tackles | Alex Karras, Detroit Lions Fred Miller, Baltimore Colts Merlin Olsen, Los Angeles Rams Floyd Peters, Philadelphia Eagles |
| Right defensive tackles | Henry Jordan, Green Bay Packers Bob Lilly, Dallas Cowboys Chuck Walker, St. Louis Cardinals |
| Outside linebackers | Chuck Howley (Left), Dallas Cowboys Dave Robinson (Left), Green Bay Packers Dave Wilcox (Left), San Francisco 49ers Maxie Baughan (Right), Los Angeles Rams Andy Russell (Right), Pittsburgh Steelers |
| Inside/middle linebackers | Dick Butkus, Chicago Bears Dale Meinert, St. Louis Cardinals Ray Nitschke, Green Bay Packers Tommy Nobis, Atlanta Falcons |
| Cornerbacks | Herb Adderly, Green Bay Packers Lem Barney, Detroit Lions Bobby Boyd, Baltimore Colts Cornell Green, Dallas Cowboys Dave Whitsell, New Orleans Saints Bob Jeter, Green Bay Packers |
| Safety | Richie Petitbon, Chicago Bears Eddie Meador, Los Angeles Rams Mel Renfro, Dallas Cowboys Larry Wilson, St. Louis Cardinals Willie Wood, Green Bay Packers |
| Special teams |
| Position | Players |
| Kickers | Jim Bakken, St. Louis Cardinals Don Chandler, Green Bay Packers |