The 2012 CollegeInsider.com Postseason Tournament (CIT) was a postseason single-elimination tournament of 32 NCAA Division I teams, up from 24 teams in the 2011 CIT. The CIT began with 16 first-round games. Games took place March 13–28, 2012.

Thirty-two participants who were not invited to the 2012 NCAA tournament, the 2012 National Invitation Tournament, or the 2012 College Basketball Invitational made up the field. The winner of the 2012 Great West Conference men's basketball tournament, North Dakota, received an automatic bid to the tournament.

All games, except for the championship game, were streamed online by America One Sports. Free registration was required to view the games. The championship game was once again broadcast nationally by Fox College Sports on FCS Central.

The tournament was won by Mercer who defeated Utah State in the championship game 70–67. This was the first post-season tournament win for a men's basketball team from the Atlantic Sun Conference.

Participating teams

The following teams received an invitation to the 2012 CIT:

SchoolConferenceOverall recordConference record
AlbanyAmerica East19–149–7
AmericanPatriot20–1110–4
Bowling GreenMid-American16–159–7
BuffaloMid-American19–1012–4
Cal State BakersfieldDivision I independent16–14
Cal State FullertonBig West21–912–4
Coastal CarolinaBig South19–1112–6
DrakeMissouri Valley17–159–9
FairfieldMetro Atlantic Athletic19–1412–6
Georgia StateColonial Athletic21–1111–7
IdahoWestern Athletic18–139–5
Indiana StateMissouri Valley17–138–10
Kent StateMid-American21–1110–6
Louisiana–LafayetteSun Belt16–1510–6
Loyola MarymountWest Coast19–1211–5
ManhattanMetro Atlantic Athletic20–1212–6
McNeese StateSouthland17–1510–6
MercerAtlantic Sun22–1113–5
North DakotaGreat West17–146–4
OaklandSummit League17–1511–7
Old DominionColonial Athletic20–1313–5
RiceConference USA17–158–8
Robert MorrisNortheast24–1013–5
Tennessee StateOhio Valley20–1211–5
Tennessee TechOhio Valley19–139–7
ToledoMid-American18–167–9
USC UpstateAtlantic Sun20–1213–5
UC Santa BarbaraBig West20–1012–4
Utah StateWestern Athletic17–158–6
Utah ValleyGreat West20–129–1
Weber StateBig Sky24–614–2
YaleIvy League19–99–5

Format

The fourth annual CIT used the old NIT model in which matchups in future rounds were determined by the results of the previous round.

Bracket

Bracket is for visual purposes only. The CIT does not have a set bracket.

First round March 13–15Second round March 17 & 18Quarterfinals March 20 & 21Semifinals March 24 & 25Championship March 28
Tennessee Tech43
Georgia State74
Georgia State59
Mercer64
Tennessee State60
Mercer68
Mercer79
Old Dominion73
Kent State58
USC Upstate73
USC Upstate56
Old Dominion65
Coastal Carolina66
Old Dominion68
Mercer64
Fairfield59
Robert Morris67
Indiana State60
Robert Morris69
Toledo51
McNeese State63
Toledo76
Robert Morris61
Fairfield67
Manhattan89
Albany79
Manhattan57
Fairfield69
Yale56
Fairfield68
Mercer70
Utah State67
North Dakota64
Drake70
Drake68
Rice74
Rice68
Louisiana–Lafayette63
Rice70
Oakland77
Buffalo78
American61
Buffalo76
Oakland84
Bowling Green69
Oakland86
Oakland81
Utah State105
Utah Valley69
Weber State72
Weber State78
Loyola Marymount84*
Cal State Fullerton79
Loyola Marymount88
Loyola Marymount69
Utah State77
UC Santa Barbara83
Idaho86
Idaho56
Utah State76
Cal State Bakersfield69
Utah State75

Home teams are listed second. * Denotes overtime period