| Offense Position First team Second team Quarterback Peyton Manning, Denver (AP, PFWA, SN) Halfback LeSean McCoy, Philadelphia (AP, PFWA, SN) Jamaal Charles, Kansas City (AP, PFWA, SN) Eddie Lacy, Green Bay (AP-2) Adrian Peterson, Minnesota (AP-2) Fullback Mike Tolbert, Carolina (AP) Marcel Reece, Oakland (AP-2) Tight end Jimmy Graham, New Orleans (AP, PFWA, SN) Vernon Davis, San Francisco (AP-2) Wide receiver Calvin Johnson, Detroit (AP, PFWA, SN) Josh Gordon, Cleveland (AP, PFWA, SN) Demaryius Thomas, Denver (AP-2) A. J. Green, Cincinnati (AP-2t) Antonio Brown, Pittsburgh (AP-2t) Tackle Jason Peters, Philadelphia (AP, PFWA, SN) Joe Thomas, Cleveland (AP) Joe Staley, San Francisco (PFWA) Tyron Smith, Dallas (SN) Tyron Smith, Dallas (AP-2) Joe Staley, San Francisco (AP-2) Guard Louis Vasquez, Denver (AP, PFWA) Evan Mathis, Philadelphia (AP, PFWA) Logan Mankins, New England (SN) Marshal Yanda, Baltimore (SN) Logan Mankins, New England (AP-2) Jahri, New Orleans (AP-2t) Josh Sitton, Green Bay (AP-2t) Center Ryan Kalil, Carolina (AP, PFWA) Alex Mack, Cleveland (SN) Alex Mack, Cleveland (AP-2) Special teams Position First team Second team Kicker Justin Tucker, Baltimore (AP, PFWA-t, SN) Stephen Hauschka, Seattle (PFWA-t) Matt Prater, Denver (AP-2) Punter Johnny Hekker, St. Louis (AP, PFWA) Brandon Fields, Miami (SN) Brandon Fields, Miami (AP-2) Return specialist Cordarrelle Patterson, Minnesota (AP, PFWA-KR, SN-KR) Dexter McCluster, Kansas City (PFWA-PR, SN-PR) Dexter McCluster, Kansas City (AP-2) Special teams Justin Bethel, Arizona (PFWA) | Defense Position First team Second team Defensive end Robert Quinn, St. Louis (AP, PFWA, SN) J. J. Watt, Houston (AP, PFWA, SN) Greg Hardy, Carolina (AP-2) Mario Williams, Buffalo (AP-2) Defensive tackle Ndamukong Suh, Detroit (AP, PFWA) Gerald McCoy, Tampa Bay (AP, PFWA, SN) Kyle Williams, Buffalo (SN) Muhammad Wilkerson, New York Jets (AP-2) Dontari Poe, Kansas City (AP-2t) Jurrell Casey, Tennessee (AP-2t) Justin Smith, San Francisco (AP-2t) Outside linebacker Lavonte David, Tampa Bay (AP, PFWA) Robert Mathis, Indianapolis (AP, PFWA, SN) Ahmad Brooks, San Francisco (AP-2) Tamba Hali, Kansas City (AP-2) Inside linebacker NaVorro Bowman, San Francisco (AP, SN) Luke Kuechly, Carolina (AP, PFWA, SN) Vontaze Burfict, Cincinnati (AP-2) Karlos Dansby, Arizona (AP-2) Cornerback Patrick Peterson, Arizona (AP, PFWA) Richard Sherman, Seattle (AP, PFWA, SN) Joe Haden, Cleveland (SN) Aqib Talib, New England (AP-2) Joe Haden, Cleveland (AP-2t) Alterraun Verner, Tennessee (AP-2t) Safety Eric Berry, Kansas City (AP, PFWA, SN) Earl Thomas, Seattle (AP, PFWA, SN) Jairus Byrd, Buffalo (AP-2) Antrel Rolle, New York Giants (AP-2t) Devin McCourty, New England (AP-2t) T. J. Ward, Cleveland (AP-2t) Kam Chancellor, Seattle (AP-2t) Eric Weddle, San Diego (AP-2t) |
| Position | First team | Second team |
| Quarterback | Peyton Manning, Denver (AP, PFWA, SN) | |
| Halfback | LeSean McCoy, Philadelphia (AP, PFWA, SN) Jamaal Charles, Kansas City (AP, PFWA, SN) | Eddie Lacy, Green Bay (AP-2) Adrian Peterson, Minnesota (AP-2) |
| Fullback | Mike Tolbert, Carolina (AP) | Marcel Reece, Oakland (AP-2) |
| Tight end | Jimmy Graham, New Orleans (AP, PFWA, SN) | Vernon Davis, San Francisco (AP-2) |
| Wide receiver | Calvin Johnson, Detroit (AP, PFWA, SN) Josh Gordon, Cleveland (AP, PFWA, SN) | Demaryius Thomas, Denver (AP-2) A. J. Green, Cincinnati (AP-2t) Antonio Brown, Pittsburgh (AP-2t) |
| Tackle | Jason Peters, Philadelphia (AP, PFWA, SN) Joe Thomas, Cleveland (AP) Joe Staley, San Francisco (PFWA) Tyron Smith, Dallas (SN) | Tyron Smith, Dallas (AP-2) Joe Staley, San Francisco (AP-2) |
| Guard | Louis Vasquez, Denver (AP, PFWA) Evan Mathis, Philadelphia (AP, PFWA) Logan Mankins, New England (SN) Marshal Yanda, Baltimore (SN) | Logan Mankins, New England (AP-2) Jahri, New Orleans (AP-2t) Josh Sitton, Green Bay (AP-2t) |
| Center | Ryan Kalil, Carolina (AP, PFWA) Alex Mack, Cleveland (SN) | Alex Mack, Cleveland (AP-2) |
| Special teams |
| Position | First team | Second team |
| Kicker | Justin Tucker, Baltimore (AP, PFWA-t, SN) Stephen Hauschka, Seattle (PFWA-t) | Matt Prater, Denver (AP-2) |
| Punter | Johnny Hekker, St. Louis (AP, PFWA) Brandon Fields, Miami (SN) | Brandon Fields, Miami (AP-2) |
| Return specialist | Cordarrelle Patterson, Minnesota (AP, PFWA-KR, SN-KR) Dexter McCluster, Kansas City (PFWA-PR, SN-PR) | Dexter McCluster, Kansas City (AP-2) |
| Special teams | Justin Bethel, Arizona (PFWA) | |
| Defense |
| Position | First team | Second team |
| Defensive end | Robert Quinn, St. Louis (AP, PFWA, SN) J. J. Watt, Houston (AP, PFWA, SN) | Greg Hardy, Carolina (AP-2) Mario Williams, Buffalo (AP-2) |
| Defensive tackle | Ndamukong Suh, Detroit (AP, PFWA) Gerald McCoy, Tampa Bay (AP, PFWA, SN) Kyle Williams, Buffalo (SN) | Muhammad Wilkerson, New York Jets (AP-2) Dontari Poe, Kansas City (AP-2t) Jurrell Casey, Tennessee (AP-2t) Justin Smith, San Francisco (AP-2t) |
| Outside linebacker | Lavonte David, Tampa Bay (AP, PFWA) Robert Mathis, Indianapolis (AP, PFWA, SN) | Ahmad Brooks, San Francisco (AP-2) Tamba Hali, Kansas City (AP-2) |
| Inside linebacker | NaVorro Bowman, San Francisco (AP, SN) Luke Kuechly, Carolina (AP, PFWA, SN) | Vontaze Burfict, Cincinnati (AP-2) Karlos Dansby, Arizona (AP-2) |
| Cornerback | Patrick Peterson, Arizona (AP, PFWA) Richard Sherman, Seattle (AP, PFWA, SN) Joe Haden, Cleveland (SN) | Aqib Talib, New England (AP-2) Joe Haden, Cleveland (AP-2t) Alterraun Verner, Tennessee (AP-2t) |
| Safety | Eric Berry, Kansas City (AP, PFWA, SN) Earl Thomas, Seattle (AP, PFWA, SN) | Jairus Byrd, Buffalo (AP-2) Antrel Rolle, New York Giants (AP-2t) Devin McCourty, New England (AP-2t) T. J. Ward, Cleveland (AP-2t) Kam Chancellor, Seattle (AP-2t) Eric Weddle, San Diego (AP-2t) |