The 1st NWHL All-Star Game took place on January 24, 2016, at HarborCenter in Buffalo, New York. The event featured two 20-minute periods in a 4-on-4 format and a Skills Competition. Team Pfalzer entered the game with a 4-0 lead having won all events in the Skills Competition.

This edition of the All-Star Game featured a "fantasy draft" format in order to determine the rosters. The team captains were Hilary Knight from the Boston Pride, and forward Emily Pfalzer, also a team captain with the Buffalo Beauts. Team Knight had the first pick overall and selected Kacey Bellamy. The captains each chose 11 players for their team.

Draft

Each captain had to select at least one player from all four teams in the NWHL. In addition, each captain had to select two goalies among their 11 selections. Two available spots on each team were determined by fan balloting, which took place from December 11–14, 2015, with winning players announced on December 15.

Team Knight
Team Knight Pick No. Nat. Player Team Pos. 1 United States Kacey Bellamy Boston Pride Defense 3 United States Kelli Stack Connecticut Whale Forward 5 Canada Kaleigh Fratkin Connecticut Whale Forward 7 Austria Janine Weber New York Riveters Forward 9 Canada Jaimie Leonoff Connecticut Whale Goaltender 11 United States Alyssa Gagliardi Boston Pride Defense 13 United States Jordan Smelker Boston Pride Forward 15 United States Brianne McLaughlin Buffalo Beauts Goaltender 17 Canada Shelby Bram Buffalo Beauts Forward 19 United States Amanda Pelkey Boston Pride Forward 21 United States Jordan Brickner Connecticut Whale DefenseTeam Pfalzer Pick No. Nat. Player Team Pos. 2 United States Brianna Decker Boston Pride Forward 4 United States Meghan Duggan Buffalo Beauts Forward 6 United States Kelley Steadman Buffalo Beauts Forward 8 Japan Nana Fujimoto New York Riveters Goaltender 10 United States Megan Bozek Buffalo Beauts Defense 12 United States Gigi Marvin Boston Pride Defence 14 United States Blake Bolden Boston Pride Defense 16 United States Brittany Ott Boston Pride Goaltender 18 United States Shiann Darkangelo Connecticut Whale Defense 20 United States Emily Field Boston Pride Defense 22 United States Zoe Hickel Boston Pride Defense
Pick No.Nat.PlayerTeamPos.
1United StatesKacey BellamyBoston PrideDefense
3United StatesKelli StackConnecticut WhaleForward
5CanadaKaleigh FratkinConnecticut WhaleForward
7AustriaJanine WeberNew York RivetersForward
9CanadaJaimie LeonoffConnecticut WhaleGoaltender
11United StatesAlyssa GagliardiBoston PrideDefense
13United StatesJordan SmelkerBoston PrideForward
15United StatesBrianne McLaughlinBuffalo BeautsGoaltender
17CanadaShelby BramBuffalo BeautsForward
19United StatesAmanda PelkeyBoston PrideForward
21United StatesJordan BricknerConnecticut WhaleDefense
Team Pfalzer
Pick No.Nat.PlayerTeamPos.
2United StatesBrianna DeckerBoston PrideForward
4United StatesMeghan DugganBuffalo BeautsForward
6United StatesKelley SteadmanBuffalo BeautsForward
8JapanNana FujimotoNew York RivetersGoaltender
10United StatesMegan BozekBuffalo BeautsDefense
12United StatesGigi MarvinBoston PrideDefence
14United StatesBlake BoldenBoston PrideDefense
16United StatesBrittany OttBoston PrideGoaltender
18United StatesShiann DarkangeloConnecticut WhaleDefense
20United StatesEmily FieldBoston PrideDefense
22United StatesZoe HickelBoston PrideDefense

Fan voting

Over 62,000 votes were cast in order to select four more players to add to the All-Star Game rosters. Madison Packer and Hayley Williams were assigned to Team Knight, while Morgan Fritz-Ward and Devon Skeats suited up with Team Pfalzer.

PlayerNationalityTeam# of votes
Madison PackerUnited StatesNew York Riveters13,397
Morgan Fritz-WardUnited StatesNew York Riveters6,948
Hayley WilliamsUnited StatesBuffalo Beauts6,384
Devon SkeatsCanadaBuffalo Beauts4,726

Game summary

The starting goaltenders in the contest were Nana Fujimoto for Team Pfalzer and Jaimie Leonoff for Team Knight.

Kelley Steadman would score the first goal in All-Star Game history, providing Team Pfalzer with the lead, as Leonoff allowed said goal. Earning the assists on Steadman's historic goal was Meghan Duggan. Adding to Team Pfalzer's lead was Emily Field, who would also score on Leonoff in the first.

In the second period, Brianne McLaughlin would replace Leonoff for Team Knight, while Brittany Ott stood between the pipes for Team Pfalzer. Along with Blake Bolden, Field and Kaleigh Fratkin, Ott would become one of four women to have competed in the 2015 Women's Winter Classic and the inaugural NWHL All-Star Game.

Steadman would score on McLaughlin, generating the first multi-goal performance in All-Star Game history. Other Team Pfalzer skaters that would score included Shiann Darkangelo and Devon Skeats, who became the first Canadian to score a goal in the NWHL All-Star Game. During the second, Hayley Williams would score the only goal of the game for Team Knight.

Skills competition

Held prior to the game itself, there were four different skills events. Whichever team would prevail in each event would gain one point that would count towards the All-Star Game's final score. Of note, Team Pfalzer captured the win in all four events at the Skills Competition, gaining four points. In the hardest shot competition, Megan Bozek was the winner, with a shot of 88 mph.