Comet McNaught as the Great Comet of 2007

A great comet is a comet that becomes exceptionally bright and easily observable to the naked eye. There is no official definition; the term is often attached to comets such as Halley's Comet, which, during certain appearances, are bright enough to be noticed by casual observers not looking for them and become well known outside the astronomical community. Typically, they are as bright or brighter than a second-magnitude star and have tails that are 10 degrees or longer under dark skies.

Great comets appear at irregular, unpredictable intervals, on average about once per decade. Although comets are officially named after their discoverers, great comets are sometimes also referred to by the year in which they appeared great, by using the formulation "The Great Comet of ...", followed by the year. The term can also be used as a generic name when a very bright comet is discovered by many observers simultaneously.

Causes

The Great Comet of 1680 over Rotterdam as painted by Lieve Verschuier

The vast majority of comets are never bright enough to be seen by the naked eye and generally pass through the inner Solar System unseen by anyone except astronomers. However, occasionally, a comet may brighten to naked eye visibility, and even more rarely, it may become as bright as or brighter than the brightest stars. The requirements for this to occur are: a large and active nucleus, a close approach to the Sun, and a close approach to the Earth. A comet fulfilling all three of those criteria will certainly be very bright.

Sometimes, a comet failing on one criterion will still be bright. For example, Comet Hale–Bopp did not approach the Sun very closely but had an exceptionally large and active nucleus. It was visible to the naked eye for several months and was very widely observed. Similarly, Comet Hyakutake was a relatively small comet but appeared bright because it passed very close to the Earth.

Size and activity of the nucleus

Cometary nuclei vary in size from a few hundreds of metres across or less to many kilometres across. When they approach the Sun, large amounts of gas and dust are ejected by cometary nuclei by solar heating. A crucial factor in how bright a comet becomes is how large and how active its nucleus is. After many returns to the inner Solar System, cometary nuclei become depleted in volatile materials and thus are much less bright than comets that are making their first passage through the Solar System.

Comets
Comet Hale–Bopp

The sudden brightening of Comet Holmes in 2007 showed the importance of the activity of the nucleus in the comet's brightness. On October 23–24, 2007, the comet underwent a sudden outburst which caused it to brighten by factor of about 480,000 times. It unexpectedly brightened from an apparent magnitude of about 17 to about 2.8 in a period of only 42 hours, making it visible to the naked eye. All of those factors temporarily made comet 17P the largest (by radius) object in the Solar System although its nucleus is estimated to be only about 3.4 km in diameter.

Close perihelion approach

The brightness of a simple reflective body varies with the inverse square of its distance from the Sun. That is, if an object's distance from the Sun is halved, its brightness is quadrupled. However, comets behave differently because of their ejection of large amounts of volatile gas, which then also reflect sunlight and may also fluoresce. Their brightness varies roughly as the inverse cube of their distance from the Sun. That is, if a comet's distance from the Sun is halved, it will become eight times as bright.

This means that the peak brightness of a comet depends significantly on its distance from the Sun. For most comets, the perihelion of their orbit lies outside the Earth's orbit. Any comet approaching the Sun to within 0.5 AU (75 million km) or less may have a chance of becoming a great comet.

Close approach to the Earth

For a comet to become very bright, it also needs to pass close to the Earth. Halley's Comet, for example, is usually very bright when it passes through the inner Solar System every 76 years, but during its 1986 apparition, its closest approach to Earth was almost the most distant possible. The comet became visible to the naked eye but unspectacular. On the other hand, the intrinsically small and faint Comet Hyakutake (C/1996 B2) appeared very bright and spectacular due to its very close approach to Earth at its nearest during March 1996. Its passage near the Earth was one of the closest cometary approaches on record, with a distance of 0.1 AU (15 million km; 39 LD).

List of great comets

Great comets of the past two millennia include the following below. This list includes multiple bright apparitions of Halley's Comet since 86 BC:

Comet
DesignationNameImageDimensions (km)(a)Total magnitude (M1)(b)Maximum brightnessPerihelion dateRemarks
X/−371Great Comet of 371 BC371 BCA winter comet reported by Aristotle and Ephorus
P/−86 Q1Halley11 km5.52.06 August 87 BCRecorded by ancient Babylonians and Chinese
C/−43 K1Caesar–4.0–9.025 May 44 BCNamed after Julius Caesar
P/−11 Q1Halley11 km5.5–5.010 October 12 BCVisible to the naked eye for 5 months
X/−4 G1Star of Bethlehem?15 April 4 BC
P/66 B1Halley11 km5.5–7.026 January 66Possibly recorded on Josephus' book, The Jewish War
P/141 F1Halley11 km5.5–4.022 March 141
X/178 R1Great Comet of 178 ADSeptember 178
X/191 T1Great Comet of 191 AD20 October 191
P/218 H1Halley11 km5.5–4.017 May 218
C/240 V1Great Comet of 240 AD4.530 November 240
X/254Great Comet of 254 ADNovember–December 254Reported tail length to be several tens of degrees. Possible progenitor/apparition of 322P/SOHO
P/295 J1Halley11 km5.5–3.020 April 295
P/374 E1Halley11 km5.5–3.017 February 374Passed within 13.5 million km from Earth
C/390 Q1Great Comet of 390 AD7.0–1.05 September 390
C/400 F1Great Comet of 400 AD6.00.025 February 400
C/442 V1Great Comet of 442 AD1.51.0–2.015 December 442
P/451 L1Halley11 km5.5–3.024 June 451Appeared before the defeat of Attila the Hun at the Battle of Chalons
P/530 Q1Halley11 km5.5–3.026 September 530
C/565 O1Great Comet of 565 AD1.50.015 July 565
C/568 O1Great Comet of 568 AD5.00.025 September 568
P/607 H1Halley11 km5.5–4.013 March 607Passed within 13 million km from Earth
X/676 P1Great Comet of 676 ADAugust–September 676Reported tail length about 7 to 8 degrees. Possibly an earlier apparition of C/1743 X1
P/684 R1Halley11 km5.5–2.028 October 684
P/760 K1Halley11 km5.5–2.022 May 760
C/770 K1Great Comet of 770 AD3.21.0–2.05 June 770
P/837 F1Halley11 km5.5–3.028 February 837Closest known approach to Earth by Halley at 5 million km
C/905 K1Great Comet of 905 AD4.50.026 April 905
P/912 J1Halley11 km5.5–2.09 July 912
P/989 N1Halley11 km5.5–1.09 September 989
P/1066 G1Halley11 km5.5–4.023 March 1066Recorded in the Bayeux tapestry
X/1106 C1Great Comet of 11061106Parent body of the Kreutz sungrazers
C/1132 T1Great Comet of 11324.5–1.030 August 1132
P/1145 G1Halley11 km5.5–2.021 April 1145Depicted on the Eadwine Psalter
P/1222 R1Halley11 km5.5–1.030 September 1222
C/1240 B1Great Comet of 12402.50.021 January 1240
C/1264 N1Great Comet of 12643.0–4.00.020 July 1264
P/1301 R1Halley11 km5.5–1.024 October 1301Depicted on the Adoration of the Magi by Giotto di Bondone
P/1378 S1Halley11 km5.5–1.09 November 1378
C/1402 D1Great Comet of 14020.0–1.0–3.021 March 1402Possibly an earlier apparition of C/1743 X1
P/1456 K1Halley11 km5.50.09 June 1456
C/1468 S1Great Comet of 14683.21.0–2.07 October 1468
C/1471 Y1Great Comet of 14712.0–3.01 March 1472Passed within 10 million km from Earth on January 1472
P/1531 P1Halley11 km5.5–1.025 August 1531
C/1532 R1Great Comet of 15321.8–1.018 October 1532
C/1533 M1Great Comet of 15333.00.015 June 1533
C/1556 D1Great Comet of 15563.0–2.022 April 1556
C/1577 V1Tycho–1.8–3.027 October 1577
P/1607 S1Halley11 km5.50.027 October 1607Apparition seen by Johannes Kepler
C/1618 W1Great Comet of 16184.60.0–1.06 December 1618
C/1664 W1Great Comet of 16642.4–1.04 December 1664
C/1665 F1Great Comet of 16654.9–1.024 April 1665
C/1668 E1Great Comet of 16686.01.0–2.028 February 1668
C/1680 V1Kirch4.01.0–2.018 December 1680Also known as Newton's Comet
P/1682 Q1Halley11 km5.5–1.015 September 1682Apparition seen by its namesake, Sir Edmond Halley
C/1686 R1Great Comet of 16865.01.0–2.016 September 1686
C/1743 X1Klinkenberg–Chéseaux0.5–7.01 March 1744
P/1758 Y1Halley11 km5.5–1.013 March 1759First successfully predicted return of Halley
C/1760 A1Great Comet of 17607.62.017 December 1759Passed within 10.2 million km from Earth
C/1769 P1Messier3.20.08 October 1769
C/1807 R1Great Comet of 18071.61.019 September 1807
C/1811 F1Flaguergues30–40 km0.012 September 1811Visible to the naked eye for 8.55 months
C/1819 N1Tralles4.01.0–2.028 June 1819
C/1823 Y1de Bréauté–Pons6.50.09 December 1823
C/1831 A1Herapath6.22.028 December 1830
P/1835 P1Halley11 km5.50.016 November 1835
C/1843 D1Great Comet of 184315.8 km4.9–3.027 February 1843Kreutz sungrazer
C/1844 Y1Great Comet of 18444.92.514 December 1844
C/1845 L1Great Comet of 18454.0–2.06 June 1845
C/1854 F1Great Comet of 18547.02.024 March 1854
C/1858 L1Donati3.30.0–1.030 September 1858First comet to be photographed
C/1861 J1Tebbutt3.90.012 June 1861
C/1865 B1Great Southern Comet of 18653.81.014 January 1865
C/1874 H1Coggia5.70.0–1.09 July 1874
C/1880 C1Great Southern Comet of 18802.2 km7.1–8.93.028 January 1880Kreutz sungrazer
C/1881 K1Tebbutt4.11.016 June 1881
C/1882 R1Great Comet of 188261.4 km0.7–17.017 September 1882Kreutz sungrazer, brightest comet ever recorded in history
C/1887 B1Thome6.311 January 1887Kreutz sungrazer
C/1901 G1Viscara9.0–1.524 April 1901
P/1909 R1Halley11 km5.50.020 April 1910
C/1910 A1Great January Comet of 19105.0–5.017 January 1910Appeared about four months before the 1910 apparition of Halley
C/1927 X1Skjellerup–Maristany5.2–4.018 December 1927
C/1947 X1Southern Comet of 19476.0–5.02 December 1947
C/1948 V1Eclipse Comet of 19489.0–1.027 October 1948
C/1956 R1Arend–Roland5.9–0.58 April 1957
C/1957 P1Mrkos4.171.01 August 1957
C/1962 C1Seki–Lines–1.51 April 1962
C/1965 S1Ikeya–Seki8.6 km–10.021 October 1965Kreutz sungrazer. Brightest comet of the 20th century
C/1969 Y1Bennett7.52 km4.60.020 March 1970
C/1975 V1West4.4–3.026 February 1976
C/1995 O1Hale–Bopp60 km–1.3–1.81 April 1997Visible to the naked eye for 18 months
C/1996 B1Hyakutake4.2 km7.40.01 May 1996Passed within 0.1 AU from Earth
C/2006 P1McNaught25 km?5.4–5.512 January 2007Brightest comet of the 21st century so far
C/2011 W3Lovejoy0.2–0.5 km15.3–4.016 December 2011Kreutz sungrazer
C/2020 F3NEOWISE5 km7.50.5–1.03 July 2020
C/2023 A3Tsuchinshan–ATLAS11.8 km6.5–4.927 September 2024
C/2024 G3ATLAS7.6–3.813 January 2025
Notes: (a)Due to a non-spherical, irregular shape, a comet's x, y, and z axes instead of an (average) diameter are often used to describe its dimensions. (b)Total magnitude (M1) as defined in Gary W. Kronk's Cometography: A Catalog of Comets book series · List ordered in ascending order by a comet's chronological apparition.

Notes

External links