| 1 | Insane Clown Posse (Shaggy 2 Dope and Violent J) | 1 | December 19, 1999 | 573 | Saint Andrew's Hall | Detroit, Michigan | JCW Volume 1 | Defeated The Doinks (Tarek the Great and Truth Martini). | |
| 2 | The Rainbow Coalition (Bob and Neil) | 1 | July 14, 2001 | 1 | SeaGate Convention Centre | Toledo, Ohio | Gathering of the Juggalos 2001 | | |
| 3 | Insane Clown Posse (Shaggy 2 Dope and Violent J) | 2 | July 15, 2001 | 2051 | SeaGate Convention Centre | Toledo, Ohio | Gathering of the Juggalos 2001 | | |
| The title was vacated in 2007 after Insane Clown Posse had stopped defending the title. |
| 4 | Mad Man Pondo and Necro Butcher | 1 | August 11, 2007 | 168 | Hog Rock | Cave-In-Rock, Illinois | Bloodymania | Defeated The Bad Breed (Axl and Ian Rotten), The Basham Brothers (Danny and Doug), The Dream Team (Brutus Beefcake and Greg Valentine), The Headshrinkers (Alofa and Samu), The Pimp 'n' Gimp Connection (Zach Gowen and Human Tornado), Jorge and Tito Santana and Team All Japan (Brute Issei and Akira Raijin) in an elimination match. | |
| 2 Tuff Tony and Violent J won the titles from Mad Man Pondo and Breyer Wellington (substituting for Necro Butcher) on January 26, 2008, but their victory was declared void, stricken from the record, and the title was vacated. |
| 5 | The Bloody Brothers (Ian and Lane Bloody) | 1 | August 10, 2008 | 132 | Hog Rock | Cave-In-Rock, Illinois | Bloodymania II | Defeated Human Tornado and The Weedman. | |
| The titles were vacated, and new champs were crowned the Big Ballas X-Mas Party 2008. |
| 6 | The Thomaselli Brothers (Pauly and Vito Thomaselli) | 1 | December 20, 2008 | 232 | Eagle Theater | Pontiac, Michigan | Big Ballas X-Mas Party '08 | The Thomaselli Brothers disguised themselves as The Ring Rydas and defeated The Bump-N-Uglies. | |
| 7 | The Weedman and Billy Bong | 1 | August 9, 2009 | 83 | Hog Rock | Cave-In-Rock, Illinois | Bloodymania III | | |
| 8 | The Thomaselli Brothers (Pauly and Vito Thomaselli) | 2 | October 31, 2009 | 288 | The Fillmore Detroit | Detroit, Michigan | Hallowicked After Party '09 | | |
| 9 | The Kings of Wrestling (Chris Hero and Claudio Castagnoli) | 1 | August 15, 2010 | 176 | Hog Rock | Cave-In-Rock, Illinois | Bloodymania IV | Won in a four-way tag team match, also involving The Ring Rydas and The Briscoe Brothers. | |
| The title was vacated in 2011 after Kings of Wrestling failed to defend it within 90 days. |
| 10 | The Haters (Pauly and Vito Thomaselli) | 3 | February 23, 2011 | 14 | The Modern Exchange | Southgate, Michigan | Flashlight Hysteria | Won an eight team battle royal. | |
| 11 | Mad Man Pondo and Necro Butcher | 2 | March 9, 2011 | 42 | The Modern Exchange | Southgate, Michigan | Hardcore Hell | Won in a hardcore barbed wire, thumbtacks, and ladders match. | |
| 12 | The Ring Rydas (Ring Ryda Blue and Red) | 1 | April 20, 2011 | 99 | The Modern Exchange | Southgate, Michigan | Up In Smoke | | |
| 13 | Raven and Sexy Slim Goody | 1 | August 14, 2011 | 139 | Hog Rock | Cave-In-Rock, Illinois | Bloodymania 5 | Won in a four team tag team match. | |
| 14 | The Ring Rydas (Ring Ryda Blue and Red) | 2 | December 31, 2011 | 862 | Worcester Palladium | Worcester, Massachusetts | New Year's Eve Ninja Party! | | |
| 15 | The Hooligans (Devin and Mason Cutter) | 1 | May 11, 2014 | 76 | Mojoe's | Joliet, Illinois | Road To The Gathering Tour – Day 7 | | |
| 16 | The Ring Rydas (Ring Ryda Blue and Red) | 3 | July 26, 2014 | 147 | Legend Valley | Thornville, Ohio | Bloodymania 8 | Won in a TLC Match | |
| 17 | The Hooligans (Devin and Mason Cutter) | 2 | December 20, 2014 | 4136 | Saint Andrew's Hall | Detroit, Michigan | Big Ballas | | |
| 18 | Mad Man Pondo and Crazy Mary Dobson | 1 (3,1) | February 21, 2015 | 155 | Detroit Masonic Temple | Detroit, Michigan | Take Me Home Charity Show | | |
| 19 | The Ring Rydas (Ring Ryda Blue and Red) | 4 | July 26, 2015 | 138 | Legend Valley | Thornville, Ohio | Bloodymania 9 | | |
| 20 | Super Strong Tiger and The Spider Monkey | 1 | December 11, 2015 | 224 | Pop's NightClub | Sauget, Illinois | The Incredible Rassle Rap Charity Festival Tour - Day 2 | | |
| 21 | The Ring Rydas (Ring Ryda Blue and Red) | 5 | July 22, 2016 | N/A | Legend Valley | Thornville, Ohio | BloodyMania 10 | This was a Fatal 4 Way TLC match also including The Viking War Party and The Hooligans. | |
| The title was vacated in 2017 or 2018, after the Ring Rydas had stopped defending the title. Their last known title defence was at JCW Juggalo Weekend 2017 - Day 2. |
| 22 | Mosh Pit Mike and Chuey Martinez | 1 | July 20, 2018 | 1356 | Legend Valley | Thornville, Ohio | BloodyMania 12 | Defeated The Hooligans for the vacant tag team championship | |
| 23 | The Brothers Of Funstruction (Yabo the Clown and Ruffo the Clown) | 1 | March 7, 2022 | 788 | The Crofoot | Pontiac, Michigan | JCW Live Event | | |
| 24 | The Southern 6 (Kerry Morton and James Storm) | 1 | May 3, 2024 | 51 | Newport Music Hall | Columbus, Ohio | JCW Lunacy: The Juggalos Strike Back | Aired on tape delay on September 18, 2024. | |
| 25 | The Backseat Boyz (JP Grayson and Tommy Grayson) | 1 | June 23, 2024 | 128 | Harpos Concert Theatre | Detroit, Michigan | JCW Lunacy | Aired on tape delay on September 25, 2024. | |
| 26 | Bang & Matthews (Davey Bang and August Matthews) | 1 | October 29, 2024 | 1 | The Forge | Joliet, Illinois | JCW Lunacy: Train of Terror Tour | | |
| 27 | The Backseat Boyz (JP Grayson and Tommy Grayson) | 2 | October 30, 2024 | 108 | Majestic Theatre | Detroit, Michigan | JCW Devil's Night | | |
| 28 | Colby Corino and Shane Mercer | 1 | February 15, 2025 | 19 | Worcester Palladium | Worcester Massachusetts | JCW Lunacy: Juggalo Weekend | Aired on tape delay on March 20, 2025. | |
| Corino and Mercer were stripped of the titles on March 6, 2025 due to a lack of title defenses. |
| 29 | The Brothers of Funstruction (Yabo the Clown and Ruffo the Clown) | 2 | March 8, 2025 | 160 | Sunshine Theater | Albuquerque, New Mexico | JCW Lunacy | Defeated The Backseat Boyz (JP Grayson and Tommy Grayson) in a tournament final. Aired on tape delay on April 10, 2025. | |
| 30 | YDNP (Alec Price and Jordan Oliver) | 1 | August 14, 2025 | 29 | Legend Valley | Thornville, Ohio | JCW vs. GCW: The 2 Day War (Night 1) | This was a Winners Take All match where YDNP's GCW World Tag Team Championship was also on the line. | |
| 31 | The Brothers of Funstruction (Yabo the Clown and Ruffo the Clown) | 3 | September 12, 2025 | 50 | Harpos Concert Theatre | Detroit, Michigan | GCW Evil Deeds | This was a Riddlebox Winners Take All match also for GCW's GCW World Tag Team Championship. This was a Game Changer Wrestling event. | |
| 32 | The Outbreak (Abel Booker and Jacksyn Crowley) | 1 | October 31, 2025 | 22 | Detroit Masonic Temple | Detroit, Michigan | JCW Lunacy: Hallowicked | Aired on tape delay on January 1, 2026, as a special episode of JCW Lunacy | |
| 33 | The Brothers of Funstruction (Yabo the Clown and Ruffo the Clown) | 4 | November 22, 2025 | 90 | Harpos Concert Theatre | Detroit, Michigan | JCW Lunacy | Aired on tape delay on January 8, 2026. | |
| -- | 2 Tuff Tony and Willie Mack | 1 | February 20, 2026 | 0 | The Vault Saginaw | Saginaw, Michigan | JCW Lunacy | Aired on tape delay on February 26, 2026. Mack & Tony won due to outside interference by Big Vito. As a result, on the following episode of Lunacy, it was announced that they refused to accept their title win, and handed the belts back to the Brothers of Funstruction. | |
| 34 | Luciano Family Enterprises (Mickie Knuckles and PCO) | 1 | February 20, 2026 | 1 | The Vault Saginaw | Saginaw, Michigan | JCW Lunacy | Aired on tape delay on March 5, 2026. | |
| 35 | 2 Tuff Tony and Willie Mack | 2 | February 21, 2026 | 55+ | Harpos Concert Theatre | Detroit, Michigan | JCW Lunacy | Aired on tape delay on March 12, 2026. | |