Paul Alexander Nolan is a Canadian actor and singer, who has appeared in several musical theatre productions across Canada and the United States.

In Canada, Nolan appeared in 9 Stratford Festival productions, including starring as Jesus in their 2011 production of Jesus Christ Superstar. In 2012, he made his Broadway debut when that same production transferred to Broadway. Since then, he has originated the roles of Jimmy Ray Dobbs in Bright Star, Tully in Escape to Margaritaville, and Jim in Slave Play. He has also played Billy Flynn in Chicago and Hugh Dorsey in the 2023 Broadway revival of Parade. He most recently appeared on Broadway in Water for Elephants, where he originated the role of August Rackinger / Charlie O'Brien.

Early life

Nolan was born and raised in Rouleau, Saskatchewan, which is a small farming community. Growing up, he developed an interest in music by listening to folk, opera, show tunes, and classical music. He attended Rouleau School, where he performed in several musicals and received vocal lessons.

He attended the Randolph College for the Performing Arts. Following college, he worked with Disney Cruise Line as a performer.

Career

In 2001, Nolan made his professional stage debut when he appeared in the ensemble for the Canadian production of Mamma Mia!, which played at the Royal Alexandra Theatre in Toronto.

Nolan made his debut with the Stratford Festival during its 2007 season, where he appeared as Slim in a production of Oklahoma!. Following this, he starred as Tony in Stratford's 2009 production of West Side Story. He also played Orlando in their 2010 production of As You Like It.

In 2011, Nolan starred as Jesus in the Stratford Festival's production of Jesus Christ Superstar. The musical then had a pre-Broadway engagement at the La Jolla Playhouse in San Diego. Nolan then made his Broadway debut in 2012 when he reprised his role of Jesus in the revival of Jesus Christ Superstar, where it played at the Neil Simon Theatre.

During the 2013 Stratford Festival season, Nolan appeared in two productions. He played Fyedka in a production of Fiddler on the Roof, and then played Cousin Kevin in a production of The Who's Tommy.

In December 2013, Nolan joined the cast of Once, playing Guy. He continued with the show until it closed in January 2015. He also played Pasha Antipov in the original Broadway production of Doctor Zhivago, which only played at the Broadway Theatre for just over a month of performances.

He also originated the role of Jimmy Ray Dobbs in the musical Bright Star, which had a pre-Broadway engagement at the Kennedy Center. The musical transferred to Broadway, where it played at the Cort Theatre for four months, closing on June 26, 2016. After this closed, he played Billy Flynn in Chicago for several weeks.

Nolan starred as Tully in the world premiere production of Escape to Margaritaville, a jukebox musical based on the songs of Jimmy Buffett, which played at the La Jolla Playhouse in 2017. He then reprised his role at subsequent pre-Broadway engagements of the musical in New Orleans, Houston, and Chicago. Nolan also reprised his role when the musical transferred to Broadway, where it opened at the Marquis Theatre.

Later in 2018, Nolan starred as Jim in the world premiere of Slave Play, a three-act play by Jeremy O. Harris. It premiered off-Broadway at the New York Theatre Workshop. He reprised the role of Jim when the play premiered on Broadway at the John Golden Theatre for a limited engagement between October 6, 2019, and January 19, 2020. Nolan again reprised his role when the play was later remounted on Broadway at the August Wilson Theatre in 2021, as well as in Los Angeles at the Mark Taper Forum in 2022.

In 2022, he starred in the world premiere of the musical Knoxville. Later in 2022, Nolan starred as Frank Carter in the musical Life After, which played at the Goodman Theatre between June 11 and July 17, 2022.

Nolan played Hugh Dorsey in the New York City Center's production of Parade. He then reprised his role when the production transferred to Broadway, where it played at the Bernard B. Jacobs Theatre for a limited engagement run between February 22, 2023, and August 6, 2023.

He also participated in a staged industry reading of Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil, based on the novel of the same name.

In 2024, Nolan originated the role of August Rackinger / Charlie O'Brien in the musical adaptation of Water for Elephants. The musical opened on Broadway at the Imperial Theatre in previews on February 24, 2024, ahead of an official opening on March 21, 2024.

Personal life

In 2014, Nolan married Canadian actress Keely Hutton, who he met while performing at the Stratford Festival.

He is a fan of the Toronto Maple Leafs.

Stage credits

YearTitleRoleLocationNotesRef.
2001-2002Mamma MiaEnsembleRoyal Alexandra TheatreMirvish Productions
2002Robin Hood: The Merry Family MusicalWill ScarletElgin TheatreRegional: Ross Petty Productions
2003Cinderella: The Sparkling Family MusicalEnsemble
2006Jesus Christ SuperstarJesusRegional: Stage West Calgary
2007King LearEnsembleFestival TheatreStratford Festival
Oklahoma!Slim
Beauty and the BeastThe BeastRegional: Persephone Theatre
2008CabaretBobbyAvon TheatreStratford Festival
2009West Side StoryTonyFestival Theatre
2009Cyrano de BergeracVicomte de Valvert
2010As You Like ItOrlando
2010The Winter's TaleEnsembleTom Patterson Theatre
2011Jesus Christ SuperstarJesusAvon Theatre
La Jolla PlayhousePre-Broadway engagement
2012Neil Simon TheatreBroadway
2012Yoshimi Battles the Pink RobotsBenLa Jolla PlayhouseWorld premiere
2013Fiddler on the RoofFyedkaFestival TheatreStratford Festival
The Who's TommyCousin KevinAvon Theatre
2013-2015OnceGuyBernard B. Jacobs TheatreBroadway (Replacement)
2015Doctor ZhivagoPasha AntipovBroadway TheatreBroadway
Daddy Long LegsJervis PendletonDavenport TheatreOff-Broadway, Original
2016Bright StarJimmy Ray DobbsKennedy CenterPre-Broadway engagement
Cort TheatreBroadway (Original)
My Fair LadyProfessor Henry HigginsBay Street TheatreRegional
ChicagoBilly FlynnAmbassador TheatreBroadway (Replacement)
2017Escape to MargaritavilleTullyLa Jolla PlayhousePre-Broadway engagement: World premiere
Saenger TheatrePre-Broadway engagement
Hobby Center
Ford Center
2018Marquis TheatreBroadway (Original)
2018-2019Slave PlayJimNew York Theatre WorkshopOff-Broadway: World premiere
2019John Golden TheatreBroadway (Original)
The Who's TommyCousin KevinLa Jolla PlayhouseConcert staging
2021-2022Slave PlayJimAugust Wilson TheatreBroadway
2022Mark Taper ForumCenter Theatre Group
KnoxvilleJay FollettAsolo Repertory TheatreWorld premiere
Life AfterFrank CarterGoodman TheatreRegional
ParadeHugh DorseyNew York City CenterOff-Broadway
2023Bernard B. Jacobs TheatreBroadway
Midnight in the Garden of Good and EvilJoe OdomStaged industry reading
2024Water for ElephantsAugust Rackinger / Charlie O'BrienImperial TheatreBroadway (Original)
2025The Bridges of Madison CountyBudCarnegie HallConcert staging
2026The Lost BoysMaxPalace TheaterBroadway (Original)

Filmography

Television

YearTitleRoleNotes
1997UncleShort film
1998Strike!Charles SchumacherFilm
1999ShapeshifterAlexFilm
2003The Visual Bible: The Gospel of JohnBridegromFilm
2003The RootDonovan KinderShort film
2018Madam SecretaryCaptain David PaleyS5.E4: "Requiem"
2019InstinctJonathan JamesS2.E1: "Stay Gold"
2019The CodeMajor Daniel ArcineauxS1.E12: "Legit Bad Day"
2020The Scottish PlayLucasFilm
2021Hudson & RexRon CrawS3.E8: "Sleeping Beauty"
2024The Broadway Show with Tamsen FadalHimselfS3.E26
2025The Gilded AgeAlfred MerrickSeason 3

Awards and nominations

YearAwardCategoryNominated workResultRef.
2015Outer Critics Circle AwardsOutstanding Featured Actor in a MusicalDoctor ZhivagoNominated
2016Drama Desk AwardOutstanding Featured Actor in a MusicalBright StarNominated

External links