Why is the second extended play (EP) by South Korean singer Taeyeon, released by SM Entertainment on June 28, 2016. Lee Soo-man, founder of SM Entertainment, served as the producer of the album. The EP saw the contributions of alternative R&B singer Dean and Taeyeon's fellow Girls' Generation member Hyoyeon. Musically, Why incorporates various genres including EDM, R&B, and Pop.

To promote the EP, Taeyeon performed on three music programs, Music Bank, Show! Music Core, and Inkigayo from July 1–3, 2016. She further embarked on her first concert tour Butterfly Kiss, which visited Seoul and Busan in July and August 2016. Upon its release, Why received generally positive reviews from media outlets, who were favorable towards the EP's diverse musical styles and Taeyeon's vocals.

The EP was a commercial success in South Korea, peaking atop the Gaon Album Chart and has sold over 110,000 physical copies in the country. It also fared well in Taiwan, charting at number two on the G-Music chart and became the second best-selling release by a South Korean artist of 2016 in the country. The EP additionally charted at numbers thirty and two on the Japanese Oricon chart and the US Billboard World Albums, respectively. Two singles from Why, "Starlight" featuring Dean and "Why" also fared well commercially, entering the top ten of South Korea's Gaon Digital Chart.

Background and release

On June 17, 2016, Taeyeon was announced to be releasing her second extended play titled Why. On June 20, it was reported that South Korean singer Dean was featured in the album. On June 22, Taeyeon's fellow Girls' Generation member Hyoyeon was revealed to be featured in the track "Up & Down".

Promotion

Taeyeon began performing "Why" on South Korean music television programs on July 1, 2016. Her first concert tour titled "Butterfly Kiss" was held in Seoul and Busan in July and August 2016 respectively.

Singles

The first single from Why, "Starlight", featuring South Korean singer Dean, and its music video were released on June 25, 2016, three days ahead of the album's release. The title track and second single, "Why", and its music video were released together with the album on June 28. A second music video for "Why", featuring the song's choreography, was released on July 7. "Starlight" and "Why" peaked at number 5 and 7 respectively on the South Korean Gaon weekly digital chart.

Reception

Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
Korea JoongAng DailyPositive
The Star8/10
The Straits Times
IdologyPositive

Why received generally positive reviews from media outlets. Lee Seo-jin from Korea JoongAng Daily praised Taeyeon's "addictive" vocal tone and wrote that the EP "proves [Taeyeon]'s potential as a solo artist". Chester Chin from The Star lauded the album's musical styles with "impressive melodies and a general feel-good vibe". He additionally complimented on Taeyeon's vocals and labelled Why as "a super solid" follow-up to her previous extended play I. Gwendolyn Ng writing for The Straits Times was mildly favorable, writing "Lead vocalist Kim slips into soloist mode with ease". However, Ng selected "Up & Down" as the EP's drawback and did not approve of Hyoyeon's contribution, saying "Hyoyeon's abrupt rapping comes in far too early and does not gel with the rest of the melody".

Why debuted at number one on the South Korean Gaon weekly album chart.

Track listing

Why
No.TitleLyricsMusicArrangementLength
1."Why"Jo Yoon-kyungLDN NoiseLauren Dyson[pl]Rodnae "Chikk" BellLDN NoiseLauren Dyson[pl]Rodnae "Chikk" Bell3:27
2."Starlight" (featuring Dean)Lee Seu-ranJamil "Digi" ChammasTaylor MckallJeremy "Tay" JasperAdrian McKinnonLeven KaliSara ForsbergMZMCJamil "Digi" ChammasTaylor MckallJeremy "Tay" JasperLeven Kali3:43
3."Fashion"Kim In-hyungLDN NoiseMarissa ShippBrittany MullenLDN NoiseMarissa ShippBrittany Mullen3:12
4."Hands on Me"Yorkie (Devine Channel)Ryu WooHarvey Mason Jr. (The Underdogs)Damon Thomas (The Underdogs)Dewain Whitmore Jr.Michael JiminezThe UnderdogsDewain Whitmore Jr.Michael Jiminez3:48
5."Up & Down" (featuring Hyoyeon)Lee Seu-ranKim Min-jiYlva Dimberg (The Kennel)Herbie CrichlowLDN NoiseYlva Dimberg (The Kennel)Herbie CrichlowLDN Noise2:53
6."Good Thing"Jung Joo-heeLDN NoiseAlice Sophie PenroseCarolyn JordanLDN NoiseAlice Sophie PenroseCarolyn Jordan2:57
7."Night"Ryu WooYorkie (Devine Channel)Im Kwang-wook (Devine Channel)[ko]Ryan Kim (Devine Channel)Im "Chase" Chae-seop[ko]Amanda Moseley (Devine Channel)Devine Channel3:13
Total length:23:13

Charts

Chart (2016)Peak position
Weekly charts Chart (2016) Peak position French Digital Albums (SNEP) 120 Japanese Albums (Oricon) 30 South Korean Albums (Gaon) 1 Taiwanese East Asian Albums (G-Music) 2 US World Albums (Billboard) 2 US Heetseekers Albums (Billboard) 15 US Independent Albums (Billboard) 48Year-end chart Chart (2016) Position South Korean Albums (Gaon) 19 Taiwanese East Asian Albums (G-Music) 2
French Digital Albums (SNEP)120
Japanese Albums (Oricon)30
South Korean Albums (Gaon)1
Taiwanese East Asian Albums (G-Music)2
US World Albums (Billboard)2
US Heetseekers Albums (Billboard)15
US Independent Albums (Billboard)48
Chart (2016)Position
South Korean Albums (Gaon)19
Taiwanese East Asian Albums (G-Music)2

Sales

CountrySales amount
South Korea112,754
Japan6,234

Release history

RegionDateFormatLabelRef.
South KoreaJune 28, 2016CDdigital downloadSM Entertainment
WorldwideDigital download
TaiwanJuly 22, 2016CDSM EntertainmentUniversal Music Taiwan

See also